Skip to main content
Get Care MyChart Find a Provider Find a Location

"Why am I always hungry when eating healthier?!  Healthy food does not fill me up!  I never seem to have that problem when I eat the other stuff!"

Hands in the air if you've ever experienced a similar situation. Many people have! And it's no surprise why—the word "healthy" is everywhere. The definition of healthy eating is what's so vastly different.  So how can you tell if you're truly eating healthy?

Next time you're sitting down to a meal or snack, try asking yourself these questions:

  1. Will the food I'm eating provide me with enough fuel to get me to my next meal or snack?

    It is a common misconception that when you eat healthy you have to be hungry all the time. In fact, if you are truly eating healthfully your meals and snacks should keep you full until it is time to eat again—usually around four hours. This is done by creating a balance of calories from the energy nutrients: carbohydrates, proteins and fats. These nutrients are broken down at different rates during digestion, so having a good balance of all three will help keep you feeling satisfied longer. Ideally, half your plate should be fruits and vegetables, a quarter of your plate should be whole grains and a quarter of your plate should be lean meats or another protein source.

  2. Is the food I'm eating going to provide me with the nutrients my body needs?

    Not only does your body need fuel, it needs other nutrients such as vitamins, minerals and phytochemicals. Balancing your plate as described above will also help you get adequate amounts of all the other nutrients your body needs to perform the important tasks it does every day to keep you alive.

  3. Am I physically hungry right now?

    Physical hunger should be the driving force behind most of your eating behaviors. If you are not physically hungry, it is important that you figure out what you really are—bored, tired, stressed, anxious, sad, lonely—so you can address that problem without using food to cope. If you are not physically hungry, it doesn't matter whether you're munching on celery or potato chips, you're still overeating.

  4. Is this a healthy eating behavior?

    When it comes to healthy eating, why you're eating is just as important as what you're eating. Not eating when you're feeling physically hungry, continuing to eat even when you're full, restricting certain foods or food groups (unless medically necessary), indulging in cheat days, feeling guilty about eating or meticulously counting calories, points, carbohydrates or pounds are all examples of unhealthy behaviors. Eat to satisfy physical hunger, and fuel your body with the energy and nutrients it needs at least 80-percent of the time. Eat just for fun or to satisfy a craving 20-percent of the time or less to stay on the right track to truly healthy eating behavior.

Remember, we live in a world driven by industry. Whether we are aware of it or not, these industries shape our perception of the world—and the diet industry is no exception. The latest and greatest diet plans and products give us any number of definitions of what constitutes a healthy food. What's important is learning to ignore all the diet noise you're surrounded by and getting back in touch with your own body. It is more than capable of telling you everything you need to know about keeping it healthy!

Related articles

Woman in exercise clothing eating healthy bowl.

Protein takeover: How much is really needed per day?

Protein's superpower is its ability to satiety. Gundersen's dietitian shares protein options and how much protein you should aim to eat daily.
woman doing dumbbell curl

What exercise burns the most calories?

Discover the benefits of anaerobic and high-intensity workouts, which help burn calories and improve overall fitness. Start your calorie-burning journey today.
Nutrition and your mental health

The link between nutrition and your mental health

The foods you eat can positively impact your brain function, mood and mental health. Apply this “back to the basics” approach of focusing on simple, healthy food for the brain
Is my child getting enough fiber

How much fiber does my child need?

Learn about the importance of fiber in a child’s diet and how to incorporate high-fiber foods for kids.

1900 South Ave.
La Crosse, WI 54601

(608) 782-7300

Language Support:
Jump back to top